The Cash Tree app, available on the Google Play Store under the package name com.cashtree.piak, has attracted over 5 million downloads with its enticing promise of earning real money by nurturing a virtual “cash tree.” Developed by Mohyou Games, the app claims to offer users rewards through activities like watching ads, playing games, and completing tasks. However, numerous user reviews label it a scam, citing issues like decreasing payouts and failure to deliver promised earnings. This review analyzes the app’s features, user feedback, and external analyses to determine its legitimacy and provide guidance for potential users.
App Description
The Cash Tree app is marketed as a personalization app that allows users to earn money by engaging with a virtual cash tree. Below is a detailed overview of its key aspects:
|
Aspect |
Details |
|---|---|
|
Developer |
Mohyou Games |
|
Platform |
Google Play Store (Link) |
|
Downloads |
Over 5 million |
|
Content Rating |
Mature 17+ |
|
Monetization |
Contains ads; users earn coins primarily by watching ads |
|
Key Features |
– Plant and nurture a virtual cash tree |
|
Playstore Link |
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.cashtree.piak&hl=en |
The app’s core mechanic involves users accumulating coins by watching ads, with the promise of converting these coins into real money once the 5000-coin threshold is reached. The simplicity of this model is appealing, but user experiences suggest significant challenges in achieving payouts.
User Reviews and Feedback
User reviews on the Google Play Store provide critical insights into the app’s performance and reliability. As of the latest data, the app has a 4.5-star rating based on 50,300 reviews, which might initially suggest high user satisfaction. However, a closer look reveals a polarized user base:
-
Positive Reviews: Some users praise the app, with comments like “It’s a good app to earn money” and “I love this app, it’s easy to earn.” These reviews are brief and lack specific details about successful payouts.
-
Negative Reviews: A significant number of users report serious issues, including:
-
Decreasing Payouts: Users note that the reward per ad decreases over time, starting at $2 and dropping to as low as 10 cents or less. One user stated, “Scam! It won’t payout! Makes you watch ads and at first it was 2$ then 1$ then 50cents then 10cents and then goes below that for watching ads.”
-
High Cash-Out Threshold: The requirement of 5000 coins to cash out ($50) is difficult to achieve, especially as rewards diminish.
-
Non-Payment: Many users report being unable to withdraw earnings, with some claiming their accounts were flagged for “fraud” after reaching the threshold.
-
Example Quote: “You have to have 5000 coins to cashout which is for 50$! Please don’t waste ya’lls time with this app! It’s 100% a scam for them to make money off you, while you get nothing.”
-
-
Developer Response: Mohyou Games responds to negative reviews with a standard message: “Dear players, we attach great importance to your feedback! We always strictly abide by relevant laws and regulations, and all reward mechanisms are open and transparent. If you have any questions, please contact us through the official email [email protected], provide your account and screenshots.” These responses are generic and do not directly address specific complaints, such as non-payment or decreasing rewards.
The high rating appears inconsistent with the volume of negative feedback, suggesting possible manipulation or a skewed distribution of reviews. The lack of detailed positive reviews further undermines the app’s credibility.
Analysis of Legitimacy
To assess whether Cash Tree is a legitimate money-making opportunity or a scam, we consider several factors:
App Mechanics
The app’s primary method of earning coins is through watching ads, a common model in “reward” apps. However, the high cash-out threshold (5000 coins = $50) and reports of decreasing payouts make it increasingly difficult for users to reach this goal. This structure suggests the app is designed to maximize ad revenue for the developer while minimizing actual payouts to users.
User Experiences
The consistent complaints about non-payment and diminishing rewards are significant red flags. Users report spending considerable time watching ads only to find that the promised rewards are unattainable. The accusation of accounts being flagged for “fraud” after reaching the cash-out threshold is a common tactic in scam apps to avoid payouts.
External Analyses
External sources provide additional context:
-
Scamadviser Reports:
-
cashtree.com.com: This related domain has an average-to-good trust score but is flagged as suspicious by IPQS. The site is currently inactive (error 503), and the owner’s identity is hidden, raising concerns about transparency (Scamadviser).
-
cashtree.app: This domain has a low trust score due to hidden owner identity, low traffic, a young domain age (registered in 2023), and being hosted in a high-risk location. It is also classified as suspicious by IPQS (Scamadviser).
-
-
Comparison to KashTree: While not directly linked, the KashTree app shares a similar name and concept. A review on gighustlers.com labels KashTree a scam, citing unrealistic claims (e.g., $44 million paid to 300,000 members in a short period), fake payment proofs, and non-payment issues (gighustlers.com). The similarities between the two apps suggest Cash Tree may follow a comparable model.
Lack of Transparency
Mohyou Games provides limited information about how the reward system works or how payouts are processed. The generic nature of their responses to user complaints and the lack of verifiable payout success stories further erode trust. Additionally, the app’s data privacy statement is vague, stating only that practices “may vary based on your use, region, and age,” without specifying what data is collected or how it is used.
Comparison with Similar Apps
The Cash Tree app operates in a crowded space of reward-based apps. Legitimate alternatives like Survey Junkie and Swagbucks have established reputations, transparent payout systems, and consistent user feedback about successful withdrawals. In contrast, Cash Tree’s reliance on ads and lack of verified payouts align it more closely with apps flagged as scams.
Security and Privacy
The app’s data safety section on the Google Play Store provides minimal details, stating only that data practices vary by region and use. The lack of clarity about data collection and sharing is concerning, especially given the app’s Mature 17+ rating, which may indicate the collection of sensitive user information. The Scamadviser reports on related domains also highlight hidden owner identities, increasing the risk of potential data misuse.
Performance
While the app is reported as “clean” from malware by Softonic, performance issues are not the primary concern. The app’s functionality appears stable, but its design—requiring extensive ad-watching—leads to user frustration rather than technical glitches. The high time investment for minimal or no reward is a significant drawback.
Conclusion
Based on user reviews, external analyses, and the app’s operational model, the Cash Tree app appears to be a scam. The evidence leans heavily toward it being designed to generate ad revenue for the developer while offering little to no genuine reward for users. Key concerns include:
-
Consistent user reports of non-payment and decreasing rewards.
-
A high cash-out threshold that is difficult to achieve.
-
Suspicious external analyses of related domains, indicating potential scam risks.
-
Lack of transparency from the developer regarding reward mechanisms and data practices.
Potential users are strongly advised to avoid the Cash Tree app to prevent wasting time and potential exposure to privacy risks.
Before downloading any money-making app, research thoroughly, read user reviews from multiple sources, and verify the developer’s credibility. Apps with transparent payout systems and consistent positive feedback are far more likely to deliver on their promises.
Disclaimer: Use this app on your personal awareness. We are just reviewing its useability and features in our article.